Editor's Choice


Common myths about machine safety

Third Quarter 2022 Editor's Choice Other technologies

The consequences of inadequate machine safety practices can be severe, and there are many misunderstandings that put facilities and their employees at risk. Omron assesses and evaluates over 3000 machines a year worldwide, and has seen how a lack of safety knowledge can lead to poorly functioning safety systems.

The consequences of inadequate machine safety practices can be severe, and there are many misunderstandings that put facilities and their employees at risk. Omron assesses and evaluates over 3000 machines a year worldwide, and has seen how a lack of safety knowledge can lead to poorly functioning safety systems.

Omron says that misconceptions about machine safety are on the rise as older, experienced workers retire in large numbers, with few mid-career workers inheriting their expertise. This trend is causing many industrial facilities to lack the engineering expertise required to ensure that their machines meet modern safety standards. In addition, an increase in the number of newer, fully automated solutions can lead to complacency, as manufacturers mistakenly believe that their new systems must be compliant.

Myth 1: If a machine is brand new, then it must be compliant

Safety is not usually a core competency of OEMs, and safety measures have become the responsibility of the end user. Manufacturers worry that safety measures hamper productivity and make processes less efficient. Although they can slow down some processes, their benefits far outweigh the costs in the long term by helping to avoid expensive, traumatic incidents.

Myth 2: Safety is too expensive and reduces productivity

The costs of an accident include not only fines and workers compensation, but also lots of productivity due to poor morale. Safety measures can be designed so they do not affect the efficiency of the machine. An example is an application that uses a safety laser scanner to minimise downtime in areas with cobots. If a worker enters the robot work area, the scanner triggers the cobot’s reduced speed mode, causing it to slow down to a safer operating level. When the employee steps out of the area, the cobot goes back to its faster speed.

Myth 3: Administrative control and employee safety training can replace good engineering

The foundation of machine safety consists of a hierarchy of controls published by NIOSH, which lists administrative controls and personal protective equipment as the least effective ways to mitigate risk. Physically removing the hazard (elimination) and replacing the hazard (substitution) are the most effective measures, but these can be impractical. Engineering controls form the middle ground for protecting operators from hazardous machine motion.

Myth 4: There are machine safeguarding exemptions for smaller companies

All companies are required to safeguard their machines properly and protect the lives and safety of their employees. What depends on company size is the amount that a company must pay in case of a safety violation. In general, regulatory agencies see enforcement actions as motivating compliance, rather than functioning as punitive measures. Regulatory bodies often have discretion in the nature and size of an enforcement action. They can issue a warning or a fine, or in extreme cases lock out non-compliant equipment.

Myth 5: When several machines are identical, it is only necessary to do a risk of assessment for one

This depends on the complexity of the machine. Even insignificant differences between machines and their positioning relative to another could change the outcome of the risk assessment.

Myth 6: If a machine was assessed before it was moved to a new location, there is no need to do another risk assessment

This depends on the complexity of the machine. When assessing access to a hazard on a machine, Omron’s safety experts use a system known by the acronym “AUTO” to determine whether an employee can reach around, under, through or over a safeguarding measure to reach the hazard area.

Myth 7: A gate using a padlock to prevent access is an acceptable safety measure

Movable guards providing protection against hazards need to be interlocked to signal the apparatus to stop. Fixed guards should be securely held in place either permanently (by welding) or by means of tamper-resistant fasteners.

Myth 8: Performance requirements for safety measures stop at the wire

Many manufacturers believe that safeguarding is only necessary when the energy source is electrical. All hazardous energy sources need to be ‘single-fault tolerant’, including hydraulic and pneumatic sources.

Myth 9: Safety is something you can take care of once and forget about it

Safety is an ongoing requirement, and companies must perform regular risk assessments on their machines to ensure that that they meet the most recent safety standards. Standards evolve with the purpose of making workplaces safer, and it is imperative for manufacturers to stay up to date to protect their employees.


Credit(s)



Share this article:
Share via emailShare via LinkedInPrint this page

Further reading:

WEG partners with Panaco in the DRC
Zest WEG Group Africa Editor's Choice News & events
The strengthened presence of WEG in the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC), through its strategic alliance with ts value-added reseller (VAR) Panaco, has proved to be highly successful.

Read more...
Execution of the massive Azmet Reactor project DRC
Editor's Choice News & events
The Azmet Reactor project, a collaborative effort led by Viva Engineering, involved fabricating six massive reactors that were over three stories high in Gauteng, and then transporting these more than 2500 kilometres to a mine in the DRC - where all 3265 parts fitted perfectly, with not even one of the 26 900 bolts out of place. This was a massive achievement.

Read more...
The time is now to implement a motor management strategy
Schneider Electric South Africa Editor's Choice Electrical switching & drive systems & components
Motor management plays an all-important role in controlling motor energy costs in various industries, segments and applications. Research and practical experience have consistently shown that effective motor management practices can result in significant energy savings, reduced operational costs, and improved overall system reliability.

Read more...
SKF’s successful raid action in Cape Town
SKF South Africa Editor's Choice Shaft power components
Authorities, with collaborative support from SKF, recently conducted a large and highly effective raid on a very well-known bearing seller of SKF bearings in Cape Town.

Read more...
Case study on automotive quality control
Motion Tronic Editor's Choice
Motion Tronic selected high-performance PLCs and HMIs from Inovance Technology to engineer a smart catalytic converter quality control solution for the exhaust facility at Toyota South Africa Motors.

Read more...
PC-based motion control on a labelling machine
Beckhoff Automation Editor's Choice Electrical switching & drive systems & components
For 50 years, Bausch+Ströbel in Germany has been developing packaging and production systems for the pharmaceutical industries. The company’s goal is to offer the best technical and economical solutions for the challenges of modern industry. Its new ESA1025 labelling machine shows how this is achieved with PC-based control from Beckhoff as the central motion controller.

Read more...
Thrust for hybrid electric flying
Editor's Choice Electrical switching & drive systems & components
Several leading academic institutes in Germany are collaborating on the future of hybrid electric flying. The partners are researching an entirely new propulsion system for medium-range aircraft with up to 35 passengers.

Read more...
Tough couplings for tough industries
Bearing Man Group T/A BMG Editor's Choice
BMG’s extensive range of power transmission components encompasses robust products from Regal Rexnord, a leading manufacturer of critical system components that perform efficiently under rigorous demands in diverse applications.

Read more...
Hydraulic connectors with residual pressure
Editor's Choice Hydraulic systems & components
Hydraulic connections are vital in both outdoor and indoor industrial machinery. However, the hydraulics lines frequently require connecting and disconnecting for maintenance or changeover. The goal is to enable quick, easy swaps to enhance machine flexibility and productivity.

Read more...
Inovance brings advanced motion control to South Africa
Motion Tronic Editor's Choice
Inovance and its South African distributor, Motion Tronic are launching the Easy Series PLC in this country, bringing its flexible, high-performance motion control solution to customers across South Africa in a wide range of industry sectors.

Read more...